Starting an Independent Insurance Agency: Lessons from Walker Insurance Agency

August 4, 2026

How Surell Walker Turned Her Success Into a Growth Platform for Other New Agents

After launching Walker Insurance Agency in Nashville, Tennessee, Surell Walker has made it a priority to share what she’s learned with aspiring insurance professionals. She believes the best education often comes from agents who’ve walked the same path, a philosophy reflected in Smart Choice’s community of independent agents.

Surell Walker, owner of Walker Insurance Agency

Key Takeaways:

  • Surell transitioned from health insurance into property and casualty insurance before launching her own independent agency.
  • Smart Choice gave her carrier access without requiring a substantial upfront fee.
  • Personal coaching and practical guidance helped her navigate unfamiliar accounts and the challenges of agency ownership.
  • Smart Start Commercial gave her the ability to write commercial policies in all 50 states.
  • Surell is now using her experience to educate, encourage and advocate for other aspiring insurance professionals.

Agency Overview

🏢
Agency Name
Walker Insurance Agency
📍
Location
Nashville, Tennessee
📋
Lines of Business
Personal and Commercial
📈
Years in Business
3 years
🚀
Agency Type
New/Growth-Focused
🤝
Smart Choice Services
Carrier Access, Coaching,
Mentorship

Building Something of Her Own

Surell Walker holding a clipboard

Surell didn’t set out to have a career in property and casualty insurance.

After earning a bachelor’s degree in healthcare management administration, she spent about eight years working in health insurance. Eventually, she was ready for a new challenge, and a friend suggested she explore the property and casualty side of the industry.

She earned her license and joined an independent agency, where she developed a love for the work and confidence in her abilities. After two years, she felt ready to take the next step. “As an independent contractor, I was already technically running my own business,” Surell says. “I figured I might as well build something for myself.”

 

Finding the Right Partner

Before launching her own agency, Surell needed carrier access. She had already worked with Smart Choice through her existing agency affiliation, so she was familiar with the network. Still, she wanted to explore her options before making such an important decision.

With a little research, she quickly ruled out several competing networks. One wanted a sizable sign-up fee. “It was like $5,000 to $8,000 down,” Surell recalls. “When you’re starting off, that’s a huge investment.”

Smart Choice offered a different approach. Instead of charging an upfront fee, they provide carrier access and agency support through a commission-sharing model with capped commissions. When agents reach leadership status, they retain 100% of their commissions.

For Surell, it made the most sense. She joined Smart Choice at the end of 2022 and officially launched Walker Insurance in 2023.

Growing with Network Support

Today, Surell has one direct carrier appointment, while the rest of her business is written through Smart Choice. While Smart Choice provides access to a broad portfolio of carriers, Surell says the personal support has been just as valuable. She especially appreciates the advice she receives from Bruce Plourde, her Tennessee state director and Angela Shelton, her territory manager. They provide practical guidance on how to place new accounts in unfamiliar business segments.

Walker Insurance Agency owner Surell Walker and Smart Choice Territory Manager Angela Shelton

“Smart Choice has definitely helped me grow, particularly because I’m able to sell commercial policies in all 50 states.”

Smart Choice support proved especially valuable during the early days of building her agency, as she discovered that owning an insurance agency is a whole different ballgame compared to working in an insurance business. “You kind of get thrown into this,” she says. “You have to learn marketing, quoting, servicing clients and even accounting – it all runs together.”

Despite the steep learning curve, she never questioned her decision. “I think I was more scared of falling into a more corporate role,” Surell admits. She wanted to build a career for herself even if it wasn’t always easy.


The Smart Choice Growth Formula
Access + Guidance + Opportunity
Surell didn’t just need carrier appointments. She needed a network that could help her navigate the realities of building and growing an independent agency.
1
Open the Door
Carrier access helped Surell launch her agency without a significant upfront investment.
2
Build with Support
Coaching and mentorship gave her practical help as she learned every side of agency ownership.
3
Multiply the Impact
As her agency grew, Surell turned her experience into guidance for the next generation of agents.
Her Success Became Someone Else’s Starting Point.

Paying It Forward

Surell Walker celebrating

As Surell’s agency grew, she noticed something unexpected. Aspiring insurance professionals began to reach out with questions about launching their own careers. They were looking for practical advice from someone who had recently gone through the same experience.

Surell began to realize that although there were plenty of resources offered online, aspiring agents were missing out on the personal side of education. They needed someone who could answer questions and offer practical advice.

She has responded by creating peer-to-peer educational content and how-to resources designed to advocate for new agents and help them understand the industry and get licensed.

 

Looking Ahead

You never know where life will take you. Surell’s career has taken plenty of twists and turns. Now she’s growing two ventures: her insurance agency and her platform for aspiring insurance agents… InsureYou. It’s a lot to juggle, but with Smart Choice, she always has support.

Whether you’re trying to start a new agency or grow an existing one, Smart Choice can help. When you join the Smart Choice network, you gain access to more than 100 carriers, plus product training and sales and marketing support.

Explore the benefits of joining Smart Choice.

How Can Smart Choice Help You?

Partner with Smart Choice and get the access, support, and flexibility you need to grow with confidence.

Become an Agency Partner